OCSD Deputy Aimee Hidalgo Expected to Plead Guilty to Voluntary Manslaughter in 2025 Tustin Shooting of Fiancée Brittany Shaw
OCSD Deputy Aimee Alexis Hidalgo is expected to enter an open guilty plea next month to voluntary manslaughter in the Aug. 8, 2025 shooting death of fiancée Brittany Shaw; attorneys are awaiting a probation report before filing sentencing arguments with Judge Bryan Clavecilla. The Nov. 6 preliminary hearing was continued with no new date yet published.
Defendant: Aimee Alexis Hidalgo, 28, OCSD deputy assigned to Orange County Jail; victim: Brittany Shaw, 35, Correctional Health worker at the same facility. Defense attorney: Paul Meyer. Presiding judge: Bryan Clavecilla.
OCSD Deputy Aimee Alexis Hidalgo faces one felony count of voluntary manslaughter with a firearm-use enhancement (PC 192(a) / PC 12022.5(a), case 26CF1300) in the shooting death of her fiancée, Brittany Shaw, 35, at their Tustin apartment on Aug. 8, 2025.
Axiom apartments, 13000 block of Tustin East Drive, Tustin; proceedings in OC Superior Court (Dept. C55 / C57).
Shooting: Aug. 8, 2025, approx. 5:10–5:20 a.m. Charged: March 9, 2026. Not-guilty plea entered: Sept. 11, 2026. Open guilty plea expected: December 2026.
Prosecutors allege Hidalgo fired nine rounds at Shaw — striking her in the torso, right arm, and head, the fatal head wound from fewer than eight inches — and claim Ring camera footage undermines Hidalgo's reported claim that she mistook Shaw for an intruder. Shaw's family wants first- or second-degree murder charges.
According to City News Service (reported Nov. 12, 2026), OCSD Deputy Aimee Alexis Hidalgo is expected to enter an open guilty plea to voluntary manslaughter with a personal gun-use enhancement in December 2026, with no agreed sentence. Defense attorney Paul Meyer stated the case has "many equities that need to be considered"; prosecutors put maximum exposure at 21 years in state prison. Attorneys are awaiting a probation report before filing sentencing arguments with Judge Bryan Clavecilla. No plea had been entered as of that report.
The Nov. 6, 2026 preliminary hearing in Dept. C57 was continued; no new date has been announced. Shaw's sister, Janeae Parrish, spoke outside court and again rejected the account that Hidalgo mistook Shaw for an intruder, citing the nine shots fired.
The shooting occurred at approximately 5:10–5:20 a.m. on Aug. 8, 2025, in the studio the couple shared at the Axiom apartments on the 13000 block of Tustin East Drive in Tustin. According to prosecutors, Ring camera footage shows Shaw leaving to walk the dog and returning roughly ten minutes later. Seconds after she re-entered, Hidalgo allegedly fired nine rounds, striking Shaw in the torso, right arm, and head. The fatal head wound was inflicted from fewer than eight inches, according to the OCDA. Hidalgo called 911 and performed CPR. The claim that Hidalgo believed Shaw was an intruder is the prosecution's allegation, not a judicial finding.
Hidalgo joined OCSD in 2021 and was assigned to the Orange County Jail. Shaw worked in Correctional Health at the same facility. The couple had planned a destination wedding in Mexico for November 2025.
The OCDA filed the voluntary manslaughter charge on March 9, 2026. Hidalgo was placed on administrative leave upon charging and remains released on a $155,000 bond posted March 16, 2026. At the Sept. 11 arraignment, approximately 40 members of Shaw's family attended. Shaw's sister told reporters the family wants first- or second-degree murder charges: "You don't shoot someone nine times on accident." The OCDA has not publicly indicated it will revise the charge.
An open guilty plea in December is now the next significant development, per City News Service. An open plea carries no agreed sentence — the judge retains full discretion up to the statutory maximum. The probation report and competing sentencing memoranda from defense and prosecution will be central to Judge Clavecilla's eventual sentencing decision. Shaw's family's push for a charge upgrade and any OCDA response remain open questions.
- Aug 8, 05:00(over 1 year ago)
Aug. 8, 2025: Brittany Shaw, 35, is shot nine times at the Tustin home she shared with her fiancée, OCSD Deputy Aimee Alexis Hidalgo; prosecutors later allege Hidalgo mistook Shaw, who was returning from walking the dog, for an intruder.
- Mar 9, 11:00(9 months ago)
March 9, 2026: The OCDA charges Hidalgo with one felony count of voluntary manslaughter with a firearm-use enhancement (case 26CF1300); she is placed on administrative leave.
- Sep 11, 10:00(2 months ago)
Friday Sept. 11: Hidalgo appears in court, where attorney Paul Meyer enters a not-guilty plea to voluntary manslaughter with a firearm enhancement; she remains free on bail, the court sets a November deadline for a pre-sentence report and the next hearing for Oct. 9. About 40 of Shaw's relatives attend and ask the OCDA to file murder charges.
- Oct 7, 10:00(about 2 months ago)
Oct. 7: Chambers work in Dept. C55 marked heard; no change to Hidalgo's not-guilty plea or bond status, per OC Superior Court docket (case 26CF1300).
- Oct 9, 10:00(about 1 month ago)
Oct. 9: Pretrial hearing in Dept. C55 marked heard; not-guilty plea to voluntary manslaughter (PC 192(a)) and denial of firearm-use enhancement (PC 12022.5(a)) stand unchanged; Hidalgo remains on $155,000 bond. Preliminary hearing set for Nov. 6 in Dept. C57.
- Nov 6(16 days ago)
Preliminary hearing in Dept. C57 is continued; no new date announced. Shaw's sister Janeae Parrish speaks outside court, again rejecting the mistaken-intruder account given the nine shots fired.
- Nov 12(10 days ago)
City News Service reports Hidalgo is expected to enter an open guilty plea to voluntary manslaughter with a personal gun-use enhancement in December 2026, with no agreed sentence. Attorneys await a probation report before filing sentencing arguments with Judge Bryan Clavecilla; defense attorney Paul Meyer says the case has 'many equities that need to be considered.' Maximum exposure remains 21 years.
- NEW2 months agoABC7: Family seeks harsher charges against Orange County sheriff's deputy accused of killing fiancée
An Orange County sheriff's deputy accused of fatally shooting her fiancée appeared in court. The victim's family says the current charge doesn't go far enough.